Saw this on Saturday: https://www.scottishopera.org.uk/shows/turandot/
I've seen Turandot twice now; the first was at the English National Opera, where the kingdom was set in a Chinese restaurant. Here Turandot's failed suitors were killed, kept on meathooks and,it was strongly inferred, fed to the customers. Never has the line "This is the door to the great butcher's shop," worked so hard.
This production is far more pure in its gothicness. If you check out the trailer down the page you can see how the chorus members all resemble some 1920s version of Doctor Frankenfurters' guests with added food fights, smeared make-up, and frantically whirling moral compass. The chorus often repeats the wish of 10,000 years to the emperor, and you can't get past the sense that he's reigned for millennia already. He isn't grand but wears the tatters of grandeur, and his front is stained with what looks suspiciously like blood. Without capes or fangs the sense of a vampire dynasty is set, and continues to the point that when the sun rises on Turandot's new life as a woman in love, the emperor staggers, whirls, and carcs it flat out across the floor. The lovers just look a bit surprised then step around his corpse as they make their way to the new dawn.
I loved the paradigm, and the music was just wonderful. Hye-Youn Lee and Trine MΓΈller felt flawless to me, though I am no expert. Victor Starsky was great excepting his performance of Nessum Dorma, which was oddly understated. If this was deliberate I get it; not only does every Nessum Dorma get compared to Pavarotti's, but perhaps there is a danger that the audience, seeing it as the musical climax of the opera, fades in attention after. Even so. It's the most famous aria in the world. Belt it out!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cWc7vYjgnTs&list=RDcWc7vYjgnTs&start_radio=1
Nobody shall sleep!
Nobody shall sleep!
Even you, oh Princess,
in your cold room,
watch the stars,
that tremble with love and with hope.
But my secret is hidden within me,
my name no one shall know...
No... No!
On your mouth, I will tell it when the light shines.
And my kiss will dissolve the silence that makes you mine!
(No one will know his name and we must, alas, die.)
Vanish, o night!
Set, stars! Set, stars!
At dawn, I will win! I will win! I will win!
Puccini died before he could finish Turandot, so from his notes and sketches, the composer Franco Alfano completed it. Arturo Toscanini, music director of La Scala, was horrified that Alfano had disregarded some of Puccini's sketches while providing his own material, and he determinedly chopped chunks out of Alfano's attempt. Alfano was shocked but Scottish Opera seems determined to mollify his memory. Throughout the world, Toscanini's editing of Alfano's version (called Alfano II) is the one performed, but Alfano's unedited version was the one used in this production. And it has to be said... Toscanini was right. It does not compare well, noodling on somewhat after the climactic kiss. Move along now, time to greet the dawn and step around the dead emperor.
We came home, had a little whisky, and R introduced me to a piece from Tosca, something about a man in a cell. I don't know what happened, given all the fun and beauty of the evening, but my heart broke to hear him, and I just wept. I'm not a great opera buff (and I hadn't had that much whisky) so can't explain how painful and beautiful it was. I think sometimes beautiful music preps you for more beautiful music til you can't take anymore and your head explodes. What other explanation can there be?
I've seen Turandot twice now; the first was at the English National Opera, where the kingdom was set in a Chinese restaurant. Here Turandot's failed suitors were killed, kept on meathooks and,it was strongly inferred, fed to the customers. Never has the line "This is the door to the great butcher's shop," worked so hard.
This production is far more pure in its gothicness. If you check out the trailer down the page you can see how the chorus members all resemble some 1920s version of Doctor Frankenfurters' guests with added food fights, smeared make-up, and frantically whirling moral compass. The chorus often repeats the wish of 10,000 years to the emperor, and you can't get past the sense that he's reigned for millennia already. He isn't grand but wears the tatters of grandeur, and his front is stained with what looks suspiciously like blood. Without capes or fangs the sense of a vampire dynasty is set, and continues to the point that when the sun rises on Turandot's new life as a woman in love, the emperor staggers, whirls, and carcs it flat out across the floor. The lovers just look a bit surprised then step around his corpse as they make their way to the new dawn.
I loved the paradigm, and the music was just wonderful. Hye-Youn Lee and Trine MΓΈller felt flawless to me, though I am no expert. Victor Starsky was great excepting his performance of Nessum Dorma, which was oddly understated. If this was deliberate I get it; not only does every Nessum Dorma get compared to Pavarotti's, but perhaps there is a danger that the audience, seeing it as the musical climax of the opera, fades in attention after. Even so. It's the most famous aria in the world. Belt it out!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cWc7vYjgnTs&list=RDcWc7vYjgnTs&start_radio=1
Nobody shall sleep!
Nobody shall sleep!
Even you, oh Princess,
in your cold room,
watch the stars,
that tremble with love and with hope.
But my secret is hidden within me,
my name no one shall know...
No... No!
On your mouth, I will tell it when the light shines.
And my kiss will dissolve the silence that makes you mine!
(No one will know his name and we must, alas, die.)
Vanish, o night!
Set, stars! Set, stars!
At dawn, I will win! I will win! I will win!
Puccini died before he could finish Turandot, so from his notes and sketches, the composer Franco Alfano completed it. Arturo Toscanini, music director of La Scala, was horrified that Alfano had disregarded some of Puccini's sketches while providing his own material, and he determinedly chopped chunks out of Alfano's attempt. Alfano was shocked but Scottish Opera seems determined to mollify his memory. Throughout the world, Toscanini's editing of Alfano's version (called Alfano II) is the one performed, but Alfano's unedited version was the one used in this production. And it has to be said... Toscanini was right. It does not compare well, noodling on somewhat after the climactic kiss. Move along now, time to greet the dawn and step around the dead emperor.
We came home, had a little whisky, and R introduced me to a piece from Tosca, something about a man in a cell. I don't know what happened, given all the fun and beauty of the evening, but my heart broke to hear him, and I just wept. I'm not a great opera buff (and I hadn't had that much whisky) so can't explain how painful and beautiful it was. I think sometimes beautiful music preps you for more beautiful music til you can't take anymore and your head explodes. What other explanation can there be?



