The Indelicate Mr Fry
Apr. 13th, 2016 01:58 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
smokingbootAs always, context helps.http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/stephen-fry-speaks-about-erosion-of-free-speech-on-student-campuses_uk_570bb53de4b07a35187c5a96
Talk about destroying one's own argument; utterly clumsy and somewhat offensive wording that leaves his original point lost while everyone gasps at his sudden outburst of insensitivity.
Because there was a good point in there somewhere; the over-enthusiastic shielding that becomes censorship lest we find ourselves facing ideas/memories/possibilities/perceptions that make us unhappy.
If we seek to live in a perpetual comfort zone of concepts, all we do is remove words, a worrying precedent to set. What problem is resolved by having neither vocabulary to define it, nor means with which to deal with it?
Survivors are not trying to hijack the world's care into a state of permanent nannying. Trigger warnings are given in order not to shut away or close down the conversation/ book/ image/concept. You get the warning, you get involved at your own risk. How is this bad?
I think he conflated a number of issues here, and the flippancy of his language really didn't help. Shot himself in the foot well and truly, the silly beggar.
Talk about destroying one's own argument; utterly clumsy and somewhat offensive wording that leaves his original point lost while everyone gasps at his sudden outburst of insensitivity.
Because there was a good point in there somewhere; the over-enthusiastic shielding that becomes censorship lest we find ourselves facing ideas/memories/possibilities/perceptions that make us unhappy.
If we seek to live in a perpetual comfort zone of concepts, all we do is remove words, a worrying precedent to set. What problem is resolved by having neither vocabulary to define it, nor means with which to deal with it?
Survivors are not trying to hijack the world's care into a state of permanent nannying. Trigger warnings are given in order not to shut away or close down the conversation/ book/ image/concept. You get the warning, you get involved at your own risk. How is this bad?
I think he conflated a number of issues here, and the flippancy of his language really didn't help. Shot himself in the foot well and truly, the silly beggar.
![[community profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/community.png){kind=small}